
Hunting for rare vintage Christmas collectibles is the best part of the holiday season! If you love the whimsical charm of the 1950s and 1960s, you are in luck. Whether you are decorating your home or scouting thrift stores, valuable mid-century holiday treasures are still hiding in plain sight. Grab your favorite drink, and let’s count down 10 rare vintage Christmas collectibles worth big money!
Mid-Century Japanese Ceramics: The Kitsch Classics
Collectors go wild for 1950s Japanese ceramic exports with their wide-eyed expressions, rosy cheeks, and hand-painted charm. Even if a piece simply says “Japan” on the bottom without a brand name, look it up before passing it by! Keep an eye out for these heavy hitters on ink stamps and red-and-gold foil labels:
- Holt-Howard: The royalty of mid-century Christmas—watch for winking and starry-eyed Santa mugs, Noel angel candleholders, and Pixieware. (Check out my Best Holt-Howard Christmas Collectibles Insider Guide for a deep dive!) Holt-Howard Santa mugs alone are major thrift-store gold, ranging from $75–$150 for classic winking Santas to an eye-popping $450–$600 per mug for the ultra-coveted Starry-Eyed Santas!
- Lefton: Sweet-faced Lefton figurines and candleholders with intact red-and-gold foil stickers typically sell for $40–$95, while rare Lefton Santa head vases, larger Nativity sets, and delicate spaghetti-trim pieces in mint condition easily command $125–$300+.
- Napco & Norcrest: Hunt for Napco’s sweet angel planters, candy cane pieces, and holiday head vases, alongside Norcrest’s expressive elves, mischievous pixies, rare snowman figures and salt and pepper shakers and Noel candleholder sets. The Payoff: Everyday mid-century Japanese planters bring a solid $25–$65, while rare Napco candy cane girls, intact Norcrest candleholder sets, and figural pixies routinely fetch $200–$375+!
- Relpo: Famous for glamorous lady head vases and season planters, Relpo also produced sought-after Japanese ceramic florist planters—always flip over Santa head vases, spaghetti-trim nodders, and holiday girl planters to look for an incised mold number or “Relpo Japan” stamp. The Payoff: Everyday holiday planters clear $35–$75, while pristine spaghetti-trim nodders and rare Relpo Santa or Christmas girl head vases can soar to $275–$450+!


COLLECTOR’S TIP: Always check mid-century ceramics for intact foil labels, un-chipped candleholders, and minimal paint flaking. Light glaze crazing is totally normal for 70-year-old pieces, but crisp paint and original stickers push values into top-dollar territory!
Vintage Santa Mugs: The Ultimate Vintage Christmas Collectible
When hunting for rare vintage Christmas collectibles, one iconic piece steals the spotlight every holiday season: the 1950s–1960s ceramic Santa mug!
- Tip #1: Look for Winking & Starry-Eyed Expressions. Mid-century Japanese mugs by Holt-Howard, Lefton, Shafford, and Stylehouse (Sears) with expressive winking faces, rosy airbrushed cheeks, and sculpted beards always outperform generic mugs.
- Tip #2: Hunt for Rare Colorways. Classic red-and-white Santas are iconic, but harder-to-find all-white glazed Santas (especially with red or gold handles) and rare pink or turquoise variants command top collector prices.
- Tip #3: Never Break Up a Set! If you spot a matching Santa pitcher or a complete Tom and Jerry eggnog bowl with mugs, grab the entire set—complete sets are dramatically rarer and bring serious money.

Iconic 1950s–1960s Vintage Christmas Collectibles

Beyond ceramics, these quintessential mid-century staples bring instant retro magic to any holiday display:
- 5. Shiny Brite Ornaments: Made in the U.S. by Max Eckardt, these iconic glass ornaments define mid-century trees—hunt for indents (reflectors), lanterns, teardrops, and coveted pink, turquoise, or chartreuse shades tucked inside their original striped boxes. The Payoff: Everyday boxed rounds sell for $35–$75, but single rare-color indents, lanterns, and stencil designs regularly command $40–$125+ each, with full boxes of pastel shades soaring to $200–$400+!
- 6. Aluminum Christmas Trees & Rotating Color Wheels: Nothing captures space-age 1960s Christmas magic quite like an Evergleam or Pom-Pom aluminum tree glowing beneath a working four-color rotating spotlight. The Payoff: Smaller tabletop trees clear $150–$350 (and working color wheels alone bring $100–$250), while complete 6- to 7-foot trees in their original boxes with branch sleeves routinely soar to $500–$1,500+!
- 7. Putz Houses & Cardboard Villages: Glitter-dusted Japanese cardboard houses with mica “snow,” loofah trees, and cellophane windows look pure magic under the tree—especially larger churches and boxed village sets. The Payoff: Single 1950s Japanese Putz houses typically bring $20–$50, while larger churches, musical houses, and complete boxed village sets with original cellophane windows and bottle-brush trees regularly fetch $150–$400+!
- 8.Vintage Bubble Lights (NOMA & Royal): Nothing captures pure 1950s Christmas magic quite like the warm, mesmerizing glow of classic NOMA or Royal bubble lights with colorful plastic bases and original illustrated boxes. The Payoff: Working 1950s strands with colorful biscuit bases typically bring $40–$90, while rare Royal “Bells,” figural bubble lights, and mint sets in their original illustrated boxes regularly fetch $150–$300+!
- 9. Rushton Rubber-Faced Plush: Made in Atlanta in the 1950s, Rushton’s soft vinyl-faced Coca-Cola Santas, Rudolphs, and winking elves with bright facial paint and intact cloth tags are ultimate thrift-store grails. The Payoff: Standard Rushton Santas and reindeer fetch $100–$200, while mint-condition Coca-Cola Santas, mischievous elves, and rare pink or white plush variants with original Atlanta tags soar to $300–$800+!
- 10. Vintage Weiss Christmas Brooches: Signed 1950s and 1960s holiday figural pins by Albert Weiss are peak mid-century sparkle. Hunt for prong-set rhinestone Christmas trees, enameled holly wreaths, and candy canes with an oval “WEISS” cartouche on the back—and double-check that every tiny chaton rhinestone is bright, original, and intact! The Payoff: Classic holly and wreath pins go for $50–$120, while elaborate multi-color Christmas trees and rare figural designs command $150–$350+!

Happy Hunting, Vintage Friends!
Whether you are adding a little 1950s sparkle to your own holiday mantel or hunting for rare vintage Christmas collectibles to rescue, remember the golden rule: always flip it over!
- Want to dive deeper into retro holiday collectibles? Explore more posts in our Vintage Christmas Collecting Series, or grab a copy of my eBook, Vintage Kitschy Christmas: A Merry Introduction to Vintage Ceramic Christmas Trees.
- Looking to add kitschy holiday cheer to your home right now? Browse my latest hand-picked finds over at my Etsy shops, Crazy4VintageChristmas and Crazy4MeStyle!
Now I want to hear from you! Pin or bookmark this cheat sheet for your next thrift run, and drop a comment below—what is the best vintage Christmas score you have ever uncovered in the wild?

















